6 Comments
User's avatar
Stephen S. Power's avatar

Started to watch the show, then gave up. Then again, I also started the book and gave that up too when, after six chapters, I was yelling at the main character, "You're a scientist! Think like a scientist! Not some schmuck from a Hitchcock movie." My wife, who'd recd the book, assured me he would start doing so soon, and he did, so I finished it. It was good. RECURSION was OK; kind of the same book, in some ways. I put down the book after that because the central idea wasn't as compelling or at least not developed in a compelling way; the tricks that worked in the first two books didn't work in that one..

Expand full comment
Matthew Greber's avatar

Yeah he eventually starts doing the same premise as The Martian - let’s problem solve and break this down to the smallest problem first. Which I very much liked. Recursion is likely the next of his I will try.

Expand full comment
Stephen S. Power's avatar

Have you read Weir's PROJECT: HAIL MARY? As good as THE MARTIAN in many ways, although there is a subtle editorial missed opportunity that bothered me, but didn't really affect the narrative.

Expand full comment
Matthew Greber's avatar

I have and I agree it’s really good. A bit concerned that the movie adaptation will be ridiculous but if they do it right …

Expand full comment
Stephen S. Power's avatar

True. It's all about making Rocky relatable. Then again, Star Trek made the Horta sympathetic, so there's hope.

Expand full comment
Matt R's avatar

I saw Dark Matter. Liked it a lot. They did it pretty well I thought. I'm sure the book is better but the TV show works.

Expand full comment